That’s a tough one… while I cling to the memory of various ‘90s girls, my ‘80s obsessions have faded. But to the best of my recollection:
Phoebe Cates, mainly for Fast Times At Ridgemont High. She also scored cool points when she married Kevin Kline.
Also, Jennifer Jason Leigh, for same. She scored cool points for playing a vast assortment of whores and victims and psychopaths in the years to come.
Kathy Ireland, of course.
Deborah Foreman, for Waxwork, wherein a high school girl gets lost in a supernatural wax museum and ends up falling in love with the whip of the Marquis de Sade.
There’s probably more, but my brain is too embarrassed to admit it. (Pretty sure I was into Madonna for about a year, around her Lucky Star period.)