My thoughts are mixed.
I’m the only person alive who didn’t care for Labyrinth and never watched Career Opportunities, for starters. (Bowie just isn’t my thing.) I warmed up to her in Inventing The Abbots, and I obviously appreciated Requiem for a Dream. (So far, Pi is the only Aronofsky I haven’t liked.) But then she moved on to clunkers like A Beautiful Mind, and if it weren’t for Daveed Diggs, I doubt I’d have watched a single episode of Snowpiercer.
She’s a competent actress who can impress when correctly cast, but like Rachel McAdams, I don’t make an effort to see her in anything.